Who is Erie Home?
The basics first, before the comparison.
Erie Home (formerly Erie Metal Roofs) is a national roofing franchise that specializes in stone-coated metal shingle systems with 50-year transferable warranties. They operate in both the St. Louis and Chicago metros through high-volume door-to-door canvassing and in-home sales presentations.
№ 001 / WHERE THEY'RE STRONG
What Erie Home does well.
Erie Home strengths
- 50-year transferable warranty on their metal shingle product
- Stone-coated metal is genuinely long-lasting if it fits your home's style
- Nationwide brand recognition
Where Vulcan is different
- We offer the same materials at transparent online pricing — no 3-hour in-home sales presentation required
- Our estimate tool gives you a real range in under 2 minutes; Erie requires a scheduled home visit before you see any number
- We don't pressure you. Our field reps arrive for inspection prepared to walk through findings, not a sales script
- We install shingle, TPO, EPDM, and torch-down in addition to metal — most homes don't need a full metal upgrade to get a durable roof
№ 002 / WHAT CUSTOMERS REPORT
Common themes from Erie Home's public reviews.
Sourced from aggregated public reviews (BBB, Google, Trustpilot). Not universal — plenty of customers have positive experiences. These are the themes that recur often enough to be worth knowing before you sit through a sales presentation.
Quotes come in 40-80% higher than local competitors for equivalent work
Sales meetings last 2-4 hours; "today only" discount pressure at the end
Hard to get a written quote without committing to a full presentation
Decision
Who should you actually call?
Erie Homeis the right call if you want a national-brand warranty, you're comfortable sitting through a full in-home sales presentation, and you have the budget for premium-tier pricing.
Vulcan Construction is the right call if you want a real price range online in 2 minutes, prefer to handle everything on your schedule without a long sales visit, and want a local contractor who meets your insurance adjuster on the roof rather than leaving you to fight the claim alone.
The honest advice: get quotes from both. Compare line items, not just totals. Our estimate tool makes that step free and non-committal — two minutes of typing and you have our number on paper.
Other comparisons